“Kids Will Be Kids”: A Refutation

Note:  I’m going to start posting my weekly Rants on this blog as well as on the Massey alumni Rants page.  Some people do like to comment on them, and these comments tend to confuse people who just want to talk about the comics.  I’ll continue to post the fortnightly comics threads, but these Ranty threads will be appearing on Mondays as well.

This week’s Rant is likely to be less goofy and sarcastic than usual.  I apologise for the lack of ironic humour.  However, this issue is one I’ve been thinking about a lot.  It seems to be ending up in the news quite frequently lately (I think the Toronto Star may have just done a series on it, but I’ve seen it elsewhere too).

I have an unfortunate habit of reacting to social situations with impulsive and bitter references to Bad Things That Happened to Me in High School.  When I do so, my acquaintances tend to respond by telling me to get over it.  High school was a long time ago; why am I still complaining about stuff that happened to me when I was fourteen?  I should grow up and move on with my life.  Theoretically, these people are correct.  I’m thirty-six, not fourteen.  I was in high school decades ago.  There is no logical reason I should still be harping on that time of my life, which is over and done with.  My references to the “unfairness” of high school doubtless come across as self-centred and pointless.

The fact that I can analyse my own behaviour like this is actually a symptom of what I am about to tell you.

I was bullied–viciously, unrelentingly, mercilessly–between the ages of eight and sixteen.  I expect that in realistic terms, the bullying began in a minor way in kindergarten and didn’t truly end until I graduated from high school, but I have a crystal-clear memory of what I think of as the beginning of the terror:  the moment in grade 3 when one of my classmates discovered that my last name sounded quite a bit like “moron.”  In grades 11 and 12, on the other hand, I was still ostracised somewhat, but I also managed to find some similarly ostracised friends, and we formed our own nerdy little defensive group of outcasts.  It was in between these two periods that my life became a living hell, and no, I do not use that term lightly.

“Kids will be kids,” adults say indulgently.  Of course there’s some bullying, but it’s harmless; it’s just children squabbling amongst themselves.  Adults who talk like this were rarely ever bullied themselves.  Being the class pariah is terrifying.  There is no other word for it.  The pariah is despised.  She is ugly, fat, stinky, clumsy, nerdy, stuck-up.  She spits when she talks, and that’s hilarious.  She is blamed for every fart, every belch.  Her clothes are wrong.  Her opinions are stupid.  She has no right to speak; she has no right to play.  If she has a friend, that friend must be weaned away from her.  She must be singled out.  She must be made to see how worthless she is, how incredibly lame her achievements are.  Anyone who treats her kindly must be ostracised too.

I wasn’t the only kid in my cohort who was treated like a worthless piece of garbage by the others; there were a number of us low on the totem pole.  We weren’t friends.  A couple of girls who were mocked for being poor stuck together, but because they were sticking together and therefore counted as a group, they saw themselves as superior to me.  I was rejected even by the other nerds.

I did play with some other kids in my neighbourhood; they tolerated me but didn’t really like me.  None of the members of this loose neighbourhood gang were in my class at school.  I had one “best” friend between grades five and seven.  Let’s call her Amelia.  She wasn’t academically gifted, but she was nice; we used to play together almost every day.  In grade seven, when the bullying was at its height, one of the boys made a loud, crude joke about me in front of the class, and Amelia laughed.  That was the end of my single real childhood friendship.  Looking back now, I realise that Amelia’s reaction was probably spontaneous and that she may not even have thought about how it might have affected me.  At the time, as a lonely twelve-year-old who spent every day in an atmosphere of hostility and mockery, I saw Amelia’s laughter as the worst sort of betrayal.

The bullying took many forms, most emotional rather than physical.  I couldn’t open my mouth without being mocked.  Everything I said was proof that I had no right to exist.  I was “Kari Moron,” the ugly, fat, smelly nerd.  I wasn’t athletic, which made the boys laugh at me.  I wasn’t pretty, which made the girls laugh at me.  My parents told me that junior high school would be better because all the bullies would have something else to occupy them and would lose interest in me.  In fact, the bullies made friends with other bullies and graduated from name-calling to physical intimidation.  One boy walked past me in class and violently punched me in the arm.  A group of boys followed me home from school, throwing rocks at me, aiming for my bum, since that was “funny.”  A boy grabbed the front of my shirt, yanked it open–breaking my necklace in the process–and shoved a handful of holly leaves down my front.  A couple of girls took me aside in class and described in detail what was wrong with me and how I could fix it.  A group of girls sat in front of my locker and refused to move.  I occasionally felt in physical danger from my classmates, the people I was expected to interact with on a daily basis.  A lot of this stuff may seem relatively trivial, but imagine enduring it day after day for eight years.

There were periods when I cried every day.  I hated going to school; I told my parents I wanted to stay home.  Contemplating another day as the class punching bag made me feel nauseous.  There was nothing I could do to stop it.  My parents advised me to “ignore” the bullying.  Any bullied child will tell you that ignoring the abuse just makes it worse.  So does fighting back.  If your classmates want to bully you, they will bully you.  Complaining to a teacher is one of the stupidest things you can do.  Snitches do not prosper in elementary or high school.  I occasionally had to beg my parents not to phone the parents of the children who had been tormenting me.  In retrospect, I suppose I was just enabling the bullying, but I was also afraid of what the bullies would do to me if their parents punished them.

When I was a very little girl, I was happy and outgoing, probably almost obnoxiously so; I wasn’t afraid to insert my opinion into any conversation.  I even remember having a crush on a boy and actually telling him to his face that I liked him.  Adults tended to describe me as “precocious.”

By the time I graduated from high school, I was seething with internal rage that I didn’t quite dare express aloud; when it escaped, I was ashamed, immediately assuming that I was in the wrong.  I had no self-esteem or self-confidence.  I knew I was a failure.  Even when I was good at things, I knew these things were essentially worthless.  I would never have dreamed of telling a boy I liked him; I would have expected to be laughed at and publicly humiliated if I had.  I hated almost everything about myself.  I thought of myself as grubby and ugly and insignificant.  I was aware that my opinions were always wrong, that my ideas were always stupid, that I didn’t really deserve to win at anything.  I did become resentful when I felt I had been treated unfairly, but the resentment was always accompanied by the thought:  “But was it really unfair?  Maybe it wasn’t.  Maybe you’re wrong again.”  I knew my natural state was to be wrong about things.

I can look back on this time of my life and see why I felt the way I felt.  What I can’t do is stop it from affecting the way I feel now.

I still feel like a failure.  I still feel as if my thoughts are worth less than everybody else’s.  When I express my opinion aloud, I expect it to be rejected; I expect everyone to be wondering at my presumption.  Even now, as I write this Rant, I am worried that its readers will roll their eyes and assume that Kari is just being Kari again.  I tend to get clingy with my friends; when they draw away from me, I take it as personally as I did the day someone made a joke about me in elementary school, and my “best friend” laughed.  I have never been in a relationship.  I would never in a million years announce to a guy that I had a crush on him.  I still feel ugly.  I’m incapable of small talk or of interacting comfortably with strangers, especially strangers I see as being superior to me (which would cover almost everyone).  I become angry very easily, and I react badly to the anger in public, then assume any confrontation is almost entirely my own fault; I also assume that everyone else is blaming me as well.  I expect not to succeed.  I approach the world so negatively that everybody sees me as a pessimist.  In reality, the pessimism is my way of steeling myself against the inevitable disappointment.

I am never going to “get over it.”

It’s hard to “get over” eight years of being told by the people you see every day that you don’t matter.  It makes you who you are.  Maybe it shouldn’t.  Maybe kids really will just be kids; maybe the fact that it still bothers me genuinely means that I am weak.  Maybe if I were a better person, I wouldn’t let my appalling childhood shape me like this.

Or maybe that appalling childhood is something I need to accept, not so that I can forget it but so that I can acknowledge that it is part of me.  Many people seem to be willing to admit to the influence of the past only when that past is a happy one or involves positive aspects such as a personal, individual triumph over a bully.  Many others will even now be thinking that my experience wasn’t that bad.  I didn’t grow up in a dictatorship.  I didn’t see family members tortured or killed.  I had rights and privileges; I had enough to eat.  I had a loving family and a place to live.  I had an education and teachers who cared about me.  This is all true.  But you can’t take a happy little girl and spend eight years telling her she is a waste of space, then expect her to remain a happy little girl.  If you dismiss her experience because she never got over it, you are implying that you could have withstood similar abuse without effect.  I would invite you to try.

Kids will be kids; that doesn’t mean kids will be reasonable or kind, and it doesn’t mean their “play” is harmless.  It also doesn’t mean that their victims will ever “get over it.”  For better or for worse, the bullying made me me.  I’m not trying to excuse my own bad behaviour or claim I shouldn’t take responsibility for being cowardly and, occasionally, anti-social; I just want you to know how hard some things are to overcome.  I can’t even say that the current me is any worse a person than a non-bullied me would have been.  She’s certainly a different one, and most likely a much sadder and more bitter one.  She is undoubtedly less well adjusted and more difficult to get along with.  But she is probably also more empathetic, more willing to see the point of view of the underdog, even if she doesn’t always show this side of herself to her acquaintances.  She is a better critical thinker, since she approaches everything from at least two perspectives simultaneously.  When she takes refuge in sarcasm, she does feel bad about it; in fact, she feels a bit like a bully herself.  She hates this aspect of her personality more than all the others combined.

And she does very much hope that children–or adults–who find it necessary to mock the “weird kids” in order to make themselves feel better will put themselves, for just an instant, in the shoes of the girl sitting alone in the corner because she is “different” somehow.

16 thoughts on ““Kids Will Be Kids”: A Refutation

  1. Rather heart-wrenching to read. I was picked on in school and had one good high school friend until he joined some club then I ate lunch in the library, yet I don’t look on those times bitterly. I don’t internalize others’ behaviors, but look at it like they were doing what they felt necessary in order for them not to be ostracized.

    From your point of view now, what should your parents and teachers done then to lessen/limit the bullying?

  2. Jimmy: I wish I could be like you, but I’m afraid I’m just not built that way. I do understand that a lot of bullies behave as they do because they are themselves afraid of being singled out. Interestingly, a recent episode of Community got it right by telling the story from the perspective of both the bully and the bullied; the bully acted to divert attention from herself and hated herself for it when she went too far, and the bullied carried that same “too far” incident with him into his thirties.

    I’m not really sure what the solution is. I don’t think my parents could have done anything more than they did; they were willing to help, but the only help they could really offer was calling the parents of the other kids, and that tended to backfire on me. They listened to me, which is all anyone can do in situations like that, and it did help. The teachers tended to pretend the bullying wasn’t happening, which was a pretty typical response in the 1980s and 1990s. I remember being sent to the school counsellor once when it all started to have a really negative effect on my life. I can’t say for sure that the bullies didn’t end up in the counsellor’s office as well, but I suspect the emphasis was on making the victims “stronger” rather than on making the bullies stop. I recall only one teacher ever mentioning bullying in front of a class; he was actually my elementary-school principal, and he was fantastic. However, nothing he said had much impact.

    If there’s a solution, it has to involve teaching empathy, but I’m not really sure how to go about that.

  3. Just… thank you. I could have written pretty much every word of it myself. Linked to it on my FB profile.

  4. I want to teach the empathy, make the students watch, Bang Bang your dead, its a very good eye opening movie,

  5. Thank you for writing this. You could have been describing my life.

    I had one teacher (sixth grade) who made a huge difference by just giving me a safe place, letting me stay in the classroom and read during recess and lunch. That was the only year I felt safe, and I did go back years later and thanked her for that.

    In my case, I told my parents at the start of eleventh grade that I was contemplating suicide because of the bullying. We made the decision for me to leave high school and go to university early, in order to keep my sanity intact. That was what saved my life. Twenty years of counselling later, I am starting to heal.

  6. I was bullied too, although not quite as badly. I was blessed by three things: I was not as low on the totem pole; I was able to go to a private high school where my mother taught and where I knew no one; and I had enough happy memories from high school to be able to block out some of the bad middle school ones. And when I say block out, I mean it literally. I forgot about the bully who slammed the locker door on my arm until my mother reminded me, and even now I don’t really remember it.

    That said, I do see elements of the things you describe in myself. I don’t assume that I am always wrong, but I too feel ugly and have never been in a relationship.

    I always assumed that high school was better for me because kids are more mature then. What teasing I did receive in high school was jokingly meant, and I soon learned to laugh it off. But now that I think about it, I probably got off easy because of my mother, who. An be damn scary.

    One of my favorite bloggers has touched on the subject of bullying before, and I think the only conclusion that can be come to is that we need to teach our children not to accept the bullying of others. Evil is when good people do nothing. But I do wonder if it will ever change.

  7. I was bullied for almost all of primary school (ages 4 1/2 to 11) and there was still a few bits and pieces at High School. My family were also subject to violence and death threats for over a decade. Bullying really sucks and no, you rarely recover quickly. For me, it took the loving careful work of trusted friends, a very good pastor and great parents. But I have recovered.

    I have absolutely no time for the “kids will be kids” argument and actually find it repulsive. Thank you so much for sharing your experience. And yes, as Earthgirl said, all we can do it teach kids that it is unacceptable. Maybe one day, with enough pressure in the right places, it will disappear.

  8. blackwolf3: wrong thread.
    Kari: maybe you can link the “comment” button to the appropriate post on the blog, rather than to the blog in general? Of course, that’d be likely to result in us complaining every 2 weeks that you forgot to update the link, but I think it’ll be worth it.

    I might write something on-topic later, when I have more time. In summary: reading the above I realize I was very lucky. The bullying at my high school was relatively mild (though I still encountered some). In the Netherlands, high school students are divided up into streams early on, with varying levels of difficulty. My school only offered the higher streams (i.e. those giving access to higher education later on). I wonder if that made the difference.

  9. Fan: I may start doing that next week (if I remember). I’ll leave it as it is until the end of this arc. Remind me again on Sunday.

    Blackwolf3: yes, I expect some people will be puzzled to see your comment. Pink elephants are symbolic shorthand for drunken hallucinations, so I felt they were inappropriate in this situation. (The comment pertains to the alt-text of one of my comics.)

    Everybody else: thank you for your comments, both public and private. It means a lot to know that people understand or want to understand.

  10. Incidentally, “wobtalk” = “Kari.” I’m logged into WordPress at the moment, so I’m appearing as my exceedingly silly username.

  11. Thank you.

    Thank you.

    On the one hand, it’s comforting that there are other people out there who might understand what I have went through.
    On the other hand, it’s said that there are other people who have had to learn about this firsthand.
    And by this, I don’t want to claim that I was as hard hit as you describe here, but I can very much relate to the anger towards the perpetrators. There are still people I haven’t been able to forgive, 16 years after graduation. People I don’t think I’ll ever forgive on a “time heals all wounds” basis – there’d have to be some other reason if I’ll be able to do so.

  12. It’s almost a decade later, but you describe me experiences very clearly, except for a few details. My grade school was in the fifties, not the eighties. Much the same. It didn’t let up until my second high school (family moved between cities) where I met a few other geeks and we got along. University was the real change, where otber students actually appreciated my academic strength and pretty well permanent willingness to discuss vtechnical problems.

  13. Hendrik: yes, I think a lot of us have been through this, unfortunately. I’m 45 now, and I just reread my post, which left me crying all over my desk. Clearly, time does not heal all wounds.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s